Premium
Comparison of Kupffer‐Phase Sonazoid‐Enhanced Sonography and Hepatobiliary‐Phase Gadoxetic Acid‐Enhanced Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Hepatocellular Carcinoma and Correlation With Histologic Grading
Author(s) -
Sugimoto Katsutoshi,
Moriyasu Fuminori,
Saito Kazuhiro,
Taira Junichi,
Saguchi Toru,
Yoshimura Nobutaka,
Oshiro Hisashi,
Imai Yasuharu,
Shiraishi Junji
Publication year - 2012
Publication title -
journal of ultrasound in medicine
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.574
H-Index - 91
eISSN - 1550-9613
pISSN - 0278-4297
DOI - 10.7863/jum.2012.31.4.529
Subject(s) - medicine , gadoxetic acid , hepatocellular carcinoma , magnetic resonance imaging , grading (engineering) , receiver operating characteristic , radiology , pathology , nodule (geology) , carcinoma , nuclear medicine , gadolinium dtpa , paleontology , civil engineering , biology , engineering
Objectives To determine the relative wash‐out of hepatocellular carcinomas and dysplastic nodules using Kupffer‐phase sonography with Sonazoid (Daiichi‐Sankyo, Tokyo, Japan) enhancement and hepatobiliary‐phase gadoxetic acid‐enhanced magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in the evaluation of the histopathologic grades of individual nodules. Methods This retrospective study included 66 consecutive patients with 78 histologically confirmed hepatocellular carcinomas and dysplastic nodules. In patients with carcinomas, 33 were well differentiated; 29 were moderately differentiated; and 11 were poorly differentiated; and there were 5 dysplastic nodules. All patients underwent both gadoxetic acid‐enhanced MRI and Sonazoid‐enhanced sonography. The interval between the two imaging examinations was less than 30 days. Six radiologists independently reviewed both images and rated the degree of relative wash‐out between the tumorous and nontumorous areas on Kupffer‐ and hepatobiliary‐phase images using a continuous rating scale. We compared these results with the histopathologic grade of each nodule, and the results were then analyzed with multireader multicase receiver operating characteristic analysis. Results The average Kupffer‐phase ( P < .001) and hepatobiliary‐phase ( P = .004) rating scores increased as the carcinomas became less differentiated (Kruskal‐Wallis test). The diagnostic accuracies of the average area under the receiver operating characteristic curve, which were estimated using the confidence levels of the relative wash‐out of the Kupffer‐ and hepatobiliary‐phase images, were 0.705 and 0.785 for dysplastic nodules versus well‐, moderately, and poorly differentiated carcinomas ( P = .517), 0.791 and 0.687 for dysplastic nodules and well‐differentiated carcinomas versus moderately and poorly differentiated carcinomas ( P = .093), and 0.871 and 0.716 for dysplastic nodules and well‐and moderately differentiated carcinomas versus poorly differentiated carcinomas ( P = .005), respectively. Conclusions Kupffer‐phase Sonazoid‐enhanced sonography and hepatobiliary‐phase gadoxetic acid‐enhanced MRI may be useful in estimating the histologic grade, although Kupffer‐phase Sonazoid‐enhanced sonography may be more accurate in distinguishing hepatocellular carcinomas, especially moderately and poorly differentiated types.