Open AccessThe ethical issues of research involving human beings contained in the editorial guidelines of Brazilian medical journals
Author(s) -
Guilherme Malafaia,
Aline Sueli de Lima Rodrigues,
André Talvani
Publication year - 2010
Publication title -
arquivos brasileiros de ciências da saúde
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
eISSN - 2358-0747
pISSN - 1983-2451
DOI - 10.7322/abcs.v35i3.80
Subject(s) - ethical issues , human research , ethical standards , engineering ethics , medical education , medical journal , institution , ethics committee , research ethics , psychology , political science , medicine , library science , family medicine , computer science , law , engineering , public administration
The present study aimed to analyze the ethical aspects contained in the sections “Instructions to authors” of Brazilian medical journals which were highly qualified on the assessment of the Qualis program of Conselho Técnico Científico da Educação Superior (CTC-ES) (Medicine I area - reference year 2007). Moreover, we searched in the journals that present information about the ethical issues involved in research with humans, if these journals inform the authors about how they should confirm to the editors the compliance with ethical issues of their studies. The editorial guidelines of 34 journals (17.6%, B2 score; 35.3% B3 score; 47.1% B4 score) were analyzed. It was observed that only 7 (20.6%) journals do no mention some ethical questions related to research involving human subjects and that 25 (73.5%) journals indicate the need for approval of research by Ethics Committee of the institution where the study was conducted. However, less than half (44.1%) of the journals clearly indicate in their “Instructions to authors” that information about the ethical aspects of research involving human subjects should be cited in the text of the manuscript submitted. Thus, further improvement is still necessary regarding the approach of ethical issues in the editorial guidelines of the Brazilian medical journals analyzed. Researches like this seek to contribute with the discussion about the awareness of editors, so that they mention in the instructions of their journals the principles, rules and ethical standards that must be considered in the research involving human beings.