Premium
Four centuries of suicide in opera
Author(s) -
Pridmore Saxby A,
Auchincloss Stephane,
Soh Nerissa L,
Walter Garry J
Publication year - 2013
Publication title -
medical journal of australia
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.904
H-Index - 131
eISSN - 1326-5377
pISSN - 0025-729X
DOI - 10.5694/mja13.10724
Subject(s) - opera , suicide prevention , psychiatry , psychology , suicide attempt , suicide methods , poison control , medicine , medical emergency , history , suicide rates , art history
Abstract Objective: To describe the depiction of completed suicide, non‐fatal suicidal acts and suicidal thought in Western opera over the past four centuries. Design and setting: Examination of synopses all of the operas listed in a recent monograph covering a selection of operas written in the period 1607–2006. Main outcome measures: Frequency of completed suicides, non‐fatal suicidal acts and suicidal thoughts over the entire 400‐year period and in separate 100‐year periods (1607–1706, 1707–1806, 1807–1906 and 1907–2006); circumstances of suicides; sex of the suicidal characters; and, for completed suicide, the method. Results: There were 337 operas in total. In 112 (33%), there was completed suicide alone, non‐fatal suicidal acts or suicidal thoughts alone, or both. There was at least one suicide in 74 operas (22%); female characters accounted for 56% of these. Non‐fatal suicidal acts or suicidal thoughts were found in 48 operas (14%); male characters accounted for 57% of these. Suicide, non‐fatal acts and suicidal thoughts always followed an undesirable event or situation. Cutting or stabbing was the most common method of suicide (26 cases). Other methods included poisoning (15 cases), drowning (10 cases), hanging (four cases), asphyxiation (four cases), “supernatural” methods (four cases), immolation (three cases), jumping from a height (two cases), shooting (one) and blunt trauma (one). Mass suicide occurred on two occasions. Conclusions: Over several centuries in opera, suicide has been frequently represented as an option when characters have been faced with a distressing event or situation. Historical fluctuations in the frequency of suicidal behaviour in opera may be explained by changes in attitudes towards suicide and its conceptualisation.