Open AccessEcho questions, echo negation, and split CP
Author(s) -
Nicholas Sobin
Publication year - 2004
Publication title -
zas papers in linguistics
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
ISSN - 1435-9588
DOI - 10.21248/zaspil.35.2004.239
Subject(s) - parallels , negation , echo (communications protocol) , inversion (geology) , architecture , mathematics , computer science , calculus (dental) , linguistics , pure mathematics , philosophy , history , geology , economics , paleontology , operations management , archaeology , structural basin , medicine , computer network , dentistry
This work examines English echo questions (EQs) against the background of Rizzi's (1997) analysis of split CP. It argues that EQs do not behave as the split CP analysis predicts that they should, and that their behavior can instead be straightforwardly explained within the classic CP analysis. Further, what are termed here 'echo negations' of negative inversion constructions are shown not to parallel EQs, a surprising result if negative inversion architecture parallels question architecture, as claimed by split CP proponents. In general, classic CP architecture is more appropriate for analysing this range of phenomena.