Open AccessContinuing the Discussion of the Spiroans and Their Entrepots: A Reply to Brooks's Critique of My New Paradigm/or the Archeology of the Arkansas Valley
Author(s) -
Frank F. Schambach
Publication year - 1996
Publication title -
index of texas archaeology
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
ISSN - 2475-9333
DOI - 10.21112/.ita.1996.1.14
Subject(s) - archaeology , value (mathematics) , history , mathematics , statistics
Although Brooks seems to agree with me that the archeology of the Arkansas Valley requires a new paradigm, he clearly believes that mine -- which he apparently considers a poorly founded Binfordian screed written primarily for its shock value -- is not the one. Where, according to Brooks, have I gone wrong in my work on the archeology of the Arkansas Valley? Which of my generalizations does he consider so poorly grounded empirically as to suggest, as he insinuates, professionally and perhaps even ethically questionable work, and in what ways does he consider them deficient?