A New Strategy of Hybrid Models using ARIMA, ANN, and DWT in Time Series Modelling

Time series forecasting is a challenging task of interest in many disciplines. A variety of techniques have been developed to deal with the problem through a combination of different disciplines. Although various researches have proved successful for hybrid models, none of them carried out the comparisons with solid statistical test. This paper proposes a new stepwise model determination method for artificial neural network (ANN) and a novel hybrid model combining autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) model, ANN and discrete wavelet transformation (DWT). Simulation studies are conducted to compare the performance of different models, including ARIMA, ANN, ARIMA-ANN, DWT-ARIMA-ANN and the proposed method, ARIMA-DWT-ANN. Also, two real data sets, Lynx data and cabbage data, are used to demonstrate the applications. Our proposed method, ARIMA-DWT-ANN, outperforms other methods in both simulated datasets and Lynx data, while ANN shows a better performance in the cabbage data. We conducted a two-way ANOVA test to compare the performances of methods. The results showed a significant difference between methods. As a brief conclusion, it is suggested to try on ANN and ARIMA-DWT-ANN due to their robustness and high accuracy. Since the performance of hybrid models may vary across data sets based on their ARIMA alike or ANN alike natures, they should all be considered when encountering a new data to reach an optimal performance.