Open AccessShould we Dispense with the Idea of Personhood? The Impoverishment of Philosophical-Theological Language
Author(s) -
José Colen,
Anthony Vecchio
Publication year - 2021
Publication title -
scripta theologica/scripta theologica
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.21
H-Index - 4
eISSN - 2254-6227
pISSN - 0036-9764
DOI - 10.15581/006.53.2.273-304
Subject(s) - personhood , articulation (sociology) , epistemology , philosophy , vocabulary , sociology , linguistics , law , political science , politics
«Who is a person?» is a question with moral, theological and even legal consequences, but it seems now apparently entangled in intractable puzzles; therefore, it has become frequent to suggest that we should entirely dispense with the idea of «personhood». This essay argues that the notions of «person», and rational «nature» which are essential in theological exploration, cannot be easily discarded from the philosophical vocabulary either. The paper argues that the preferred route of access should preserve the noetic heterogeneity of beings, because it is the current «scientistic» straitjacket that has made very articulation of the question fruitless and impoverished.