Open AccessCounterstatement to Article Entitled "A Framework for Evaluation of Marine Spatial Data Geoportals Using Case Studies"
Author(s) -
Christian Seip
Publication year - 2015
Publication title -
geoscience engineering
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
ISSN - 1802-5420
DOI - 10.1515/gse-2015-0023
Subject(s) - misconduct , scientific misconduct , engineering ethics , data science , sociology , political science , computer science , engineering , law , medicine , alternative medicine , pathology
In December 2014 in volume 60 issue 4 a paper was published entitled “A Framework for Evaluation of Marine Spatial Data Geoportals Using Case Studies” by Marina Tavra, Vlado Cetl and Tea Duplancic Leder which is suspected to constitute academic misconduct. This comment reasons that the core of the paper was taken from another source and thus does not offer new and original scientific work and therefore does not add knowledge to the body of science. Furthermore it argues that apart from the plagiarism the paper shows major weaknesses and thus should have not been published even it was not plagiarized