Open AccessPopulation correlations do not support the existence of set points for blood levels of calcium or glucose – a new model for homeostasis
Author(s) -
Fitzgerald Stephen P.,
Bean Nigel G.
Publication year - 2018
Publication title -
physiological reports
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.918
H-Index - 39
ISSN - 2051-817X
DOI - 10.14814/phy2.13551
Subject(s) - population , glucose homeostasis , homeostasis , hormone , set point , set (abstract data type) , biology , endocrinology , computer science , medicine , diabetes mellitus , insulin resistance , engineering , programming language , environmental health , control engineering
The prevailing teaching regarding homeostasis, and in particular endocrine homeostasis, includes the fundamental concept of a “set point,” which represents a target or optimum level defended by physiological control mechanisms. Analogies for the description and teaching of this concept have included thermostats and cruise controls. We previously demonstrated that such a set‐point model of regulation implies that in population data of parameter set point/controlling hormone levels, correlations between the parameter and its controlling hormone must be in the direction of the response of the parameter to its controlling hormone, and that in thyroid homeostasis this relationship is not observed. In this work we similarly examined population correlations, extracted from the literature, for the parameters glucose and calcium, and their controlling hormones. We found 10 correlations. Most were highly significant ( P < 0.01). All were in the direction of the response of the controlling hormone to the parameter. Therefore, none were consistent with the pattern implied by a set‐point model of regulation. Instead all were consistent with an “equilibrium point” model of regulation, whereby ambient levels have no particular connotation to the individual, and result passively from the interplay of physiological processes. We conclude that glucose and calcium regulation, like thyroid regulation, are not centered on set points. This may reflect a general property of homeostasis. We provide an alternative mechanistic analogy, without a set point, for the heuristic description and teaching, of homeostasis.