Open AccessDiagnostic performance of chest computed tomography during the epidemic wave of COVID-19 varied as a function of time since the beginning of the confinement in France
Author(s) -
Samia Boussouar,
Mathilde Wagner,
Victoria Donciu,
Nicoletta Pasi,
JoeElie Salem,
Raphaële Renard-Penna,
Stéphane Marot,
Yonathan Freund,
Alban Redheuil,
O. Lucidarme
Publication year - 2020
Publication title -
plos one
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.99
H-Index - 332
ISSN - 1932-6203
DOI - 10.1371/journal.pone.0242840
Subject(s) - covid-19 , medicine , pneumonia , population , computed tomography , nuclear medicine , radiology , pathology , disease , environmental health , outbreak , infectious disease (medical specialty)
Objective To evaluate the diagnostic performance of the initial chest CT to diagnose COVID-19 related pneumonia in a French population of patients with respiratory symptoms according to the time from the onset of country-wide confinement to better understand what could be the role of the chest CT in the different phases of the epidemic. Material and method Initial chest CT of 1064 patients with respiratory symptoms suspect of COVID-19 referred between March 18 th , and May 12 th 2020, were read according to a standardized procedure. The results of chest CTs were compared to the results of the RT-PCR. Results 546 (51%) patients were found to be positive for SARS-CoV2 at RT-PCR. The highest rate of positive RT-PCR was during the second week of confinement reaching 71.9%. After six weeks of confinement, the positive RT-PCR rate dropped significantly to 10.5% (p<0.001) and even 2.2% during the two last weeks. Overall, CT revealed patterns suggestive of COVID-19 in 603 patients (57%), whereas an alternative diagnosis was found in 246 patients (23%). CT was considered normal in 215 patients (20%) and inconclusive in 1 patient. The overall sensitivity of CT was 88%, specificity 76%, PPV 79%, and NPV 85%. At week-2, the same figures were 89%, 69%, 88% and 71% respectively and 60%, 84%, 30% and 95% respectively at week-6. At the end of confinement when the rate of positive PCR became extremely low the sensitivity, specificity, PPV and NPV of CT were 50%, 82%, 6% and 99% respectively. Conclusion At the peak of the epidemic, chest CT had sufficiently high sensitivity and PPV to serve as a first-line positive diagnostic tool but at the end of the epidemic wave CT is more useful to exclude COVID-19 pneumonia.