Open AccessPrecision and reliability of tape measurements in the assessment of head and neck lymphedema
Author(s) -
Adit Chotipanich,
Nampheng Kongpit
Publication year - 2020
Publication title -
plos one
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.99
H-Index - 332
ISSN - 1932-6203
DOI - 10.1371/journal.pone.0233395
Subject(s) - medicine , tape measure , reliability (semiconductor) , lymphedema , standard deviation , head and neck cancer , nuclear medicine , head and neck , reproducibility , gold standard (test) , accuracy and precision , orthodontics , surgery , radiology , statistics , mathematics , breast cancer , cancer , physics , radiation therapy , power (physics) , geometry , quantum mechanics
Objectives Tape measurement is a commonly used method in the clinical assessment of lymphedema. However, few studies have assessed the precision and reliability of tape measurement in assessing head and neck lymphedema. This study aimed to evaluate the reliability and precision of using tape measurement, performed by different evaluators, for the assessment of head and neck lymphedema. Methods This study was conducted at a tertiary care cancer hospital. Between January and December 2019, 50 patients with head and neck cancers and 50 normal subjects were enrolled. Each subject was examined using tape measurements for 7 point-to-point distances of facial landmarks, 3 circumferences of the neck (upper, middle, and lower), and 2 circumferences of the face (vertical and oblique) by 3 random examiners. Test precision and reliability were assessed with the within-subject standard deviation (S w ) and intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC), respectively. Results Overall, the standard deviation of the tape measurements varied in the range of 4.6 mm to 18.3 mm. The measurement of distance between the tragus and mouth angle (S w : 4.6 mm) yielded the highest precision, but the reliability (ICC: 0.66) was moderate. The reliabilities of neck circumference measurements (ICC: 0.90–0.95) were good to excellent, but the precisions (S w : 8.3–12.3 mm) were lower than those of point-to-point facial measurements (S w : 4.6–8.8 mm). Conclusions The different methods of tape measurements varied in precision and reliability. Thus, clinicians should not rely on a single measurement when evaluating head and neck lymphedema.