z-logo
open-access-imgOpen Access
Oral Examination versus Simulation-Based Assessment in Assessing Patient Care Competencies for Emergency Medicine Residents
Author(s) -
Bamadhaf Wail
Publication year - 2022
Publication title -
dubai medical journal
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
ISSN - 2571-726X
DOI - 10.1159/000525868
Subject(s) - educational corner – research article
Background: Assessment is essential for any accreditation process in the medical field. If a candidate passes a high-stakes assessment, they can work independently. While oral examinations are common, given the complexity of clinical competencies, such an approach may not be the most effective assessment method. A form of performance-based assessment, such as a simulation, may be beneficial in this context. Objectives: This study aims to determine whether the results of oral examinations match those of simulation-based assessments when both modalities are used to evaluate residents’ performance in scenarios featuring similar content. It also seeks to determine whether oral examinations under- or overestimate residents’ competencies concerning patient care when compared to their simulation performance. Methods: This is a cross-sectional, single-centre study. Emergency medicine residents underwent an oral examination and completed a simulation-based assessment. Standardized scenarios were used to assess the residents’ emergency medicine competencies. A global rating scale was used to rate participants’ performance in each assessment modality. Results: There was a moderate positive correlation between oral examination and simulation-based assessment results ( r = 0.699, p < 0.05, n = 28). A paired t test indicates that the oral examination overestimates residents’ competency compared to the simulation-based assessment; the mean difference is 0.26 (confidence interval: 0.041–0.493). Conclusions: Emergency medicine residents whose knowledge was assessed at the “know-how” level of Miller’s pyramid in the oral examination were not necessarily able to move up to the level of “show-how” by demonstrating the ability to apply their knowledge in the simulation-based assessment. The findings of this study confirm that simulation-based assessments should be an essential aspect of high-stakes examinations intended to determine residents’ different clinical competencies.

The content you want is available to Zendy users.

Already have an account? Click here to sign in.
Having issues? You can contact us here