From a Comprehensive Experimental Survey to a Cost-based Selection Strategy for Lightweight Integer Compression Algorithms

Lightweight integer compression algorithms are frequently applied in in-memory database systems to tackle the growing gap between processor speed and main memory bandwidth. In recent years, the vectorization of basic techniques such as delta coding and null suppression has considerably enlarged the corpus of available algorithms. As a result, today there is a large number of algorithms to choose from, while different algorithms are tailored to different data characteristics. However, a comparative evaluation of these algorithms with different data and hardware characteristics has never been sufficiently conducted in the literature. To close this gap, we conducted an exhaustive experimental survey by evaluating several state-of-the-art lightweight integer compression algorithms as well as cascades of basic techniques. We systematically investigated the influence of data as well as hardware properties on the performance and the compression rates. The evaluated algorithms are based on publicly available implementations as well as our own vectorized reimplementations. We summarize our experimental findings leading to several new insights and to the conclusion that there is no single-best algorithm. Moreover, in this article, we also introduce and evaluate a novel cost model for the selection of a suitable lightweight integer compression algorithm for a given dataset.