Open AccessFree Fallin’? The decline in evidence-based decision-making by Canada’s protected areas managers
Author(s) -
Christopher J. Lemieux,
Elizabeth Halpenny,
Trevor Swerdfager,
Mu He,
A. Joyce Gould,
Don Carruthers Den Hoed,
Jill Bueddefeld,
Glen T. Hvenegaard,
Brian Joubert,
Rick Rollins
Publication year - 2021
Publication title -
facets
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.51
H-Index - 9
ISSN - 2371-1671
DOI - 10.1139/facets-2020-0085
Subject(s) - indigenous , accountability , traditional knowledge , value (mathematics) , public relations , business , perception , environmental resource management , scientific evidence , evidence based policy , political science , psychology , ecology , economics , medicine , machine learning , neuroscience , computer science , law , biology , philosophy , alternative medicine , epistemology , pathology
The conservation of biodiversity requires various forms of evidence to ensure effective outcomes. In this study, we provide an updated assessment of the state of evidence-based decision-making in Canada’s protected areas organizations by examining practitioner perceptions of: ( i) the value and use of various forms of evidence, ( ii) the availability of evidence to support decisions, and ( iii) the extent to which various institutional and behavioural barriers influence the use of evidence. Our results compare national surveys conducted in 2019 and 2013, revealing a significant and concerning decline in the use of all forms of evidence. We found significant declines in the use of peer-reviewed literature, local knowledge, and Indigenous knowledge. Our results correspondingly demonstrate a host of systemic barriers to the effective use of evidence, including a lack of trust, how to deal with uncertainty, and limited training. These challenges persist at a time when the quantity of information is greater than ever, and recognition of the value of Indigenous knowledge is relatively high (and increasing). Leadership is required to cultivate more relevant evidence, to embed scientists and Indigenous Knowledge-Holders in conservation organizations, to (re)establishing knowledge sharing forums, and to establish accountability and reporting measures to support efforts aimed at effectively achieving Canada’s biodiversity conservation goals.