z-logo
open-access-imgOpen Access
The gift of life – does it apply to donation for research?
Author(s) -
Raivola Vera
Publication year - 2020
Publication title -
isbt science series
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
eISSN - 1751-2824
pISSN - 1751-2816
DOI - 10.1111/voxs.12533
Subject(s) - donation , metaphor , blood donor , altruism (biology) , context (archaeology) , solidarity , analogy , social psychology , psychology , public relations , medicine , political science , epistemology , law , theology , politics , immunology , paleontology , philosophy , biology
In his influential study, “The Gift Relationship” [1970], Richard Titmuss coined the idea of voluntary, non‐paid, blood donation being the gift of life for a fellow citizen. This metaphor has been powerful in mobilising donors. It conveys a direct relationship between blood donation and patients’ vitality, as well as a difference between gains and costs. As the gift of life, blood donation is seen to symbolise pure altruism and promoting solidarity between strangers. But can we apply the metaphor as successfully to donating blood for research? I interviewed a group of Finnish blood donors on what if the FRC Blood Service invited them to give a blood sample and personal information for research. The blood donors were usually willing to contribute to research for the public benefit, because they saw great potential in science to create solutions to help patients in the future. However, based on our interview data and previous research, I suggest that the analogy between the gift of life and donation for research did not work all the way. The metaphor fails to address donors’ questions on the new types of relationships, interests and risks related to the use of personal data for research. Left unanswered, these could discourage donating for research. Hence, I argue that the gift of life metaphor is not applicable to donor recruitment in the research context. I propose to look for new metaphors that resonate better with donors’ perceptions of research participation and serve the communication needs of data collectors.

The content you want is available to Zendy users.

Already have an account? Click here to sign in.
Having issues? You can contact us here