Premium
Does item overlap render measured relationships between pain and challenging behaviour trivial? Results from a multicentre cross‐sectional study in 13 German nursing homes
Author(s) -
Kutschar Patrick,
Bauer Zsuzsa,
Gnass Irmela,
Osterbrink Jürgen
Publication year - 2017
Publication title -
nursing inquiry
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.66
H-Index - 49
eISSN - 1440-1800
pISSN - 1320-7881
DOI - 10.1111/nin.12182
Subject(s) - dementia , psychology , scale (ratio) , cognition , cross sectional study , german , nursing homes , association (psychology) , item response theory , status quo , psychometrics , clinical psychology , medicine , nursing , psychiatry , disease , physics , archaeology , pathology , quantum mechanics , economics , market economy , history , psychotherapist
Several studies suggest that pain is a trigger for challenging behaviour in older adults with cognitive impairment. However, such measured relationships might be confounded due to item overlap as instruments share similar or identical items. The purpose of this study was to examine whether the frequently observed association between pain and challenging behaviour might be traced back to item overlap. This multicentre cross‐sectional study was conducted in 13 nursing homes and examined pain (measure: Pain Assessment in Advanced Dementia Scale) and challenging behaviour (measure: Cohen‐Mansfield Agitation Inventory) in 150 residents with severe cognitive impairment. The extent of item overlap was determined by juxtaposition of both measures’ original items. As expected, comparison between these instruments revealed an extensive item overlap. The statistical relationship between the two phenomena can be traced back mainly to the contribution of the overlapping items, which renders the frequently stated relationship between pain and challenging behaviour trivial. The status quo of measuring such associations must be contested: constructs’ discrimination and instruments’ discrimination have to be discussed critically as item overlap may lead to biased conclusions and assumptions in research as well as to inadequate care measures in nursing practice.