Premium
Extrinsic Grace and Eccentric Existence
Author(s) -
McAnnallyLinz Ryan
Publication year - 2015
Publication title -
modern theology
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.144
H-Index - 19
eISSN - 1468-0025
pISSN - 0266-7177
DOI - 10.1111/moth.12111
Subject(s) - parallels , teleology , philosophy , narrative , relation (database) , criticism , eccentric , extant taxon , theology , position (finance) , epistemology , literature , physics , art , biology , economics , computer science , operations management , linguistics , finance , database , evolutionary biology , quantum mechanics
Catherine Pickstock has critiqued David Kelsey's Eccentric Existence for, among other things, adopting the position on the relation of nature to grace that has become known as “extrinsicism”. Pickstock's critique of Kelsey parallels the criticism that both she and John Milbank have leveled against extrinsicism. This paper considers the merits of Pickstock's charges of extrinsicism and supposedly related theological ills against Kelsey. Finding that they fall short, I suggest that Kelsey's “three narrative” anthropology and its “multiple teleology” are potentially valuable resources for ongoing theological debates concerning nature and grace.