Premium
Influence of learner knowledge and case complexity on handover accuracy and cognitive load: results from a simulation study
Author(s) -
Young John Q,
Dijk Savannah M,
O'Sullivan Patricia S,
Custers Eugene J,
Irby David M,
Cate Olle
Publication year - 2016
Publication title -
medical education
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 1.776
H-Index - 138
eISSN - 1365-2923
pISSN - 0308-0110
DOI - 10.1111/medu.13107
Subject(s) - handover , cognition , cognitive load , context (archaeology) , cognitive model , psychology , computer science , harm , maturity (psychological) , scripting language , cognitive psychology , social psychology , developmental psychology , psychiatry , computer network , paleontology , biology , operating system
Context The handover represents a high‐risk event in which errors are common and lead to patient harm. A better understanding of the cognitive mechanisms of handover errors is essential to improving handover education and practice. Objectives This paper reports on an experiment conducted to study the effects of learner knowledge, case complexity (i.e. cases with or without a clear diagnosis) and their interaction on handover accuracy and cognitive load. Methods Participants were 52 Dutch medical students in Years 2 and 6. The experiment employed a repeated‐measures design with two explanatory variables: case complexity (simple or complex) as the within‐subject variable, and learner knowledge (as indicated by illness script maturity) as the between‐subject covariate. The dependent variables were handover accuracy and cognitive load. Each participant performed a total of four simulated handovers involving two simple cases and two complex cases. Results Higher illness script maturity predicted increased handover accuracy (p < 0.001) and lower cognitive load (p = 0.007). Case complexity did not independently affect either outcome. For handover accuracy, there was no interaction between case complexity and illness script maturity. For cognitive load, there was an interaction effect between illness script maturity and case complexity, indicating that more mature illness scripts reduced cognitive load less in complex cases than in simple cases. Conclusions Students with more mature illness scripts performed more accurate handovers and experienced lower cognitive load. For cognitive load, these effects were more pronounced in simple than complex cases. If replicated, these findings suggest that handover curricula and protocols should provide support that varies according to the knowledge of the trainee.