Premium
Developing Discussion of Language Change Into a Three‐Dimensional Model of Linguistic Phenomena
Author(s) -
Hawkey James
Publication year - 2016
Publication title -
language and linguistics compass
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.619
H-Index - 44
ISSN - 1749-818X
DOI - 10.1111/lnc3.12180
Subject(s) - linguistics , language change , viewpoints , prestige , linguistic change , sociology , history , philosophy , physics , acoustics
The concepts of change from above (CFA) and change from below (CFB) have been employed by sociolinguists for decades: but ‘above’ and ‘below’ what exactly? Popularised by William Labov, these terms are most frequently used to describe complementary, highly distinct processes of language change. Subsequent interpretations have subtly altered the definitions of these terms, and as a result, CFA and CFB have been used to refer to different things by different people. Often, the resultant phenomena are not as complementary or distinct as they first seem. This article analyses the various interpretations of CFA and CFB with an aim to clarify how the terms have been used, and to propose a new and thorough taxonomical model for linguistic phenomena. Leading scholarly viewpoints are examined (Labov [Labov, William, 1972], Crystal [Crystal, David, 1987], Ferguson [Ferguson, Charles, 1987], Wolfram and Schilling‐Estes [Wolfram, Walt, 1998], Ellis [Ellis, Donald G., 1999], Romaine [Romaine, Suzanne, 2003] inter alia ), and three bifurcating axes are formed, revealing what ‘above’ and ‘below’ variously relate to. The axes of +/– metacommentary, +/– overt prestige and +/– planned will be explained and formed into a three‐dimensional model of linguistic phenomena, thus constituting an innovative development in the ongoing debate surrounding CFA and CFB.