Premium
MARKET TESTING AND PRISON RIOTS: HOW PUBLIC‐SECTOR COMMERCIALIZATION CONTRIBUTED TO A PRISON RIOT
Author(s) -
RYNNE JOHN,
HARDING RICHARD W.,
WORTLEY RICHARD
Publication year - 2008
Publication title -
criminology and public policy
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 1.6
H-Index - 33
eISSN - 1745-9133
pISSN - 1538-6473
DOI - 10.1111/j.1745-9133.2008.00495.x
Subject(s) - prison , competition (biology) , private sector , public sector , procurement , commercialization , public policy , political science , economics , public administration , economic growth , economy , law , management , ecology , biology
Research Summary: Macroeconomic reforms have swept many modern Western corrections jurisdictions into a world of commercial realities, privatization, and competition. The following case study reviews how competition (i.e., a market test) between the public and the private sectors in tendering for the operation of the Woodford Corrections Centre contributed to a riot. A combined model of the threshold and state‐centered theories of prison riots provides a template that clarifies the interactions of factors that contributed to the riot. Through document analysis and interviews, it is evident that despite producing a highly innovative bid judged superior to the private sector, the public sector was caught in a policy bind that led to a prison riot 3 weeks after the new center opened. Policy Implications: This research highlights important policy considerations for governments initiating policy‐driven prison reform. First, the research highlights the need for custodial policy development and implementation to be strategic and part of an overall reform agenda that considers prison riot theory. Second, if the public sector is to be involved in open competition with the private sector, then policy should be consistent with the conditions of the competition. Prisons, whether public or private, cannot cope successfully with reformist policy that does not consider adequately the interactions of the individuals in the prison.