Premium
The Usefulness of Design of Experimentation in Defining the Effect Difficult Airway Factors and Training Have on Simulator Oral–Tracheal Intubation Success Rates in Novice Intubators
Author(s) -
Thomas Frank,
Carpenter Judi,
Rhoades Carol,
Holleran Renee,
Snow Gregory
Publication year - 2010
Publication title -
academic emergency medicine
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 1.221
H-Index - 124
eISSN - 1553-2712
pISSN - 1069-6563
DOI - 10.1111/j.1553-2712.2010.00706.x
Subject(s) - medicine , intubation , trismus , airway , airway obstruction , anesthesia , tracheal intubation , physical therapy , tongue , surgery , pathology
Objectives: This exploratory study examined novice intubators and the effect difficult airway factors have on pre‐ and posttraining oral–tracheal simulation intubation success rates. Methods: Using a two‐level, full‐factorial design of experimentation (DOE) involving a combination of six airway factors (curved vs. straight laryngoscope blade, trismus, tongue edema, laryngeal spasm, pharyngeal obstruction, or cervical immobilization), 64 airway scenarios were prospectively randomized to 12 critical care nurses to evaluate pre‐ and posttraining first‐pass intubation success rates on a simulator. Scenario variables and intubation outcomes were analyzed using a generalized linear mixed‐effects model to determine two‐way main and interactive effects. Results: Interactive effects between the six study factors were nonsignificant (p = 0.69). For both pre‐ and posttraining, main effects showed the straight blade (p = 0.006), tongue edema (p = 0.0001), and laryngeal spasm (p = 0.004) significantly reduced success rates, while trismus (p = 0.358), pharyngeal obstruction (p = 0.078), and cervical immobilization did not significantly change the success rate. First‐pass intubation success rate on the simulator significantly improved (p = 0.005) from pre‐ (19%) to posttraining (36%). Conclusions: Design of experimentation is useful in analyzing the effect difficult airway factors and training have on simulator intubation success rates. Future quality improvement DOE simulator research studies should be performed to help clarify the relationship between simulator factors and patient intubation rates. ACADEMIC EMERGENCY MEDICINE 2010; 17:460–463 © 2010 by the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine