Modeling Animals' Behavioral Response by Markov Chain Models for Capture–Recapture Experiments

Summary A bivariate Markov chain approach that includes both enduring (long‐term) and ephemeral (short‐term) behavioral effects in models for capture–recapture experiments is proposed. The capture history of each animal is modeled as a Markov chain with a bivariate state space with states determined by the capture status (capture/noncapture) and marking status (marked/unmarked). In this framework, a conditional‐likelihood method is used to estimate the population size and the transition probabilities. The classical behavioral model that assumes only an enduring behavioral effect is included as a special case of the bivariate Markovian model. Another special case that assumes only an ephemeral behavioral effect reduces to a univariate Markov chain based on capture/noncapture status. The model with the ephemeral behavioral effect is extended to incorporate time effects; in this model, in contrast to extensions of the classical behavioral model, all parameters are identifiable. A data set is analyzed to illustrate the use of the Markovian models in interpreting animals' behavioral response. Simulation results are reported to examine the performance of the estimators.