Premium
The Replication Problem in Sociology: A Report and a Suggestion *
Author(s) -
WILSON FRANKLIN D.,
SMOKE GALE L.,
MARTIN J. DAVID
Publication year - 1973
Publication title -
sociological inquiry
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.446
H-Index - 51
eISSN - 1475-682X
pISSN - 0038-0245
DOI - 10.1111/j.1475-682x.1973.tb00711.x
Subject(s) - replication (statistics) , statistical inference , inference , sociology , positive economics , epistemology , computer science , psychology , statistics , economics , artificial intelligence , mathematics , philosophy
The deleterious effects of joint bias in favor of statistical inference and against replication are becoming well known. The acceptance of numerous Type I errors into the literature is by far the most serious of these. Data on the contents of three major journals support the contention that a joint bias for statistical significance tests, for rejections, and against replication exists in modern sociology. This finding replicates that of Sterling (1959) for psychology. A speculative analysis of the dynamics of publication decisions suggests that a compact format for reporting replications might make their publication more attractive to editors, and thus increase their frequency in the literature. A possible format for briefly reporting replication studies is suggested.