Habitat partitioning and antagonistic behaviour amongst the birds of a West African scrub and plantation plot

A study was made of feeding patterns and antagonistic behaviour amongst 11 common bird species frequenting an abandoned rubber plantation and scrub plot in southern Nigeria. The examination of feeding patterns involved a comparison of foraging habits and an analysis of the use made by each species of the major vertical and horizontal subdivisions of the habitat. Two species of muscicapid flycatchers showed a striking similarity, both in foraging habits and their use of the major habitat zones. In general, however, species with otherwise similar foraging habits were found to feed in habitat zones which were spatially separated. A number of these latter species showed antagonistic reactions to one another. However, unlike most reported instances of such behaviour in birds, neither species in the pairs we observed played a consistently dominant role. Dominance was usually shown by whichever individual made most use, for feeding purposes, of the encounter zone. Under these circumstances it seems possible that interspecific antagonism allows species to adjust to local variations in habitat structure and to capitalise on the temporary absence of potential competitors. In which case it is more appropriate to regard this type of behaviour as an important component in the process of habitat partitioning, rather than to dismiss it as an activity which will ultimately be rendered redundant in the course of evolution.