Premium
Straddling Two Worlds: Reflections of a Retired Criminal Cases Review Commissioner
Author(s) -
Duff Peter
Publication year - 2009
Publication title -
the modern law review
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.37
H-Index - 22
eISSN - 1468-2230
pISSN - 0026-7961
DOI - 10.1111/j.1468-2230.2009.00764.x
Subject(s) - commission , law , appeal , economic justice , criminal justice , political science , royal commission , criminal law , sociology
In this paper, I draw upon the ‘systems theory’ approach to miscarriages of justice (adopted by Nobles and Schiff) to reflect upon my experience as a member of the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission. I demonstrate how the Commission manages the tensions between the rather different ‘legal’ and ‘lay’ worlds which it inhabits. More particularly, I argue that the Commission, while heavily constrained by the law and a legal world view, is more independent of the legal ‘system’ than some commentators would suggest. I substantiate my arguments through describing some of the debates that took place within the Scottish Commission and analysing in depth the judgements of the Scottish appeal court in some of the cases referred to it by the Commission. Much of what I say is applicable in varying degrees to the English Commission and to the current debate in England as to what constitutes a ‘miscarriage of justice’.