‘Anything You Can Do I Can Do Better’: Dialectical Argument in Philosophy of Education 1

Drawing upon my critical appropriation of Alasdair MacIntyre's account of the rationality of traditions, I undertake to explain and demonstrate how the competing conceptual frameworks of distinct traditions of educational inquiry and practice can be assessed through dialectical argument. To illustrate the ‘method’ of dialectic, I argue that the set of metaethical commitments I call ‘the ethics of transcendent virtue’ has important advantages for teaching courses in professional ethics over the ‘constructivist‐postmodern‐moral‐pragmatism’ informing Robert J. Nash's text ‘Real world’ Ethics: Frameworks for Educators and Human Service Professionals. I conclude with reflections upon the conditions under which dialectical encounters among proponents of different conceptual schemes are likely to be productive.