Premium
ES04
*DIAGNOSTIC LOBECTOMY IS NOT ROUTINELY REQUIRED TO DIAGNOSE THYROID CANCER IN NODULES GREATER THAN OR EQUAL TO 4CM IN SIZE?
Author(s) -
Raj M. D.,
Grodski S.,
Yeung M.,
Serpell J.
Publication year - 2009
Publication title -
anz journal of surgery
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.426
H-Index - 70
eISSN - 1445-2197
pISSN - 1445-1433
DOI - 10.1111/j.1445-2197.2009.04916_4.x
Subject(s) - medicine , thyroid nodules , malignancy , thyroid cancer , radiology , thyroid , incidence (geometry) , pathology , physics , optics
Purpose: The current gold standard for determining malignancy in thyroid nodules >4 cm is diagnostic lobectomy, regardless of the fine needle aspirate cytology (FNAC) result. This is based on the reportedly high false‐negative rates of FNAC (>10%) in large thyroid nodules. The purpose of this study was to determine if routine removal of thyroid nodules >4 cm is best clinical practice. We hypothesize that ultrasound guided FNAC is as effective as diagnostic lobectomy in detecting malignancy in these patients. Method: We conducted a cross sectional study of 225 consecutive patients with thyroid nodules >4 cm between 1994 and 2008 who all underwent surgical excision. We assessed the efficacy of preoperative FNAC alone in detecting malignancy in this group compared to surgical excision. Results: 225 patients in the study underwent surgery. 162 patients had preoperative FNAC performed. Male to female ratio was 1:3. Overall incidence of thyroid cancer was 9.6% (16/165). The sensitivity of preoperative FNAC alone in identifying thyroid cancer was 81% and specificity was 62%. False negative rate for FNAC was 1/16 (6%). Positive predictive value of FNAC was 22% (13/60), with negative predictive value of 99% (90/91). Likelihood ratio for positive FNAC result was 2.13. Conclusion: The incidence of carcinoma in thyroid nodules less than 4 cm is low. Preoperative FNAC is highly sensitive and specific in detecting thyroid cancer even in nodules less than 4 cm in size. Effective management of these patients can be confidently carried out based on the preoperative FNAC result alone, without the need for diagnostic lobectomy.