Effect of Population Density, Size of Habitat and Oviposition Substrate on the Breeding System of Pupfish ( Cyprinodon pecosensis )

Size of habitat, availability of oviposition substrate, and population density were manipulated to determine their effects on the structure and dynamics of the pupfish breeding system. The fish established a territorial breeding system in large tanks, irrespective of population density or oviposition substrate. A dominance hierarchy, in which one male controlled most of the oviposition substrate and spawned with most females, was established in small tanks at low densities. Both population density and oviposition substrate affected the number of males defending territories. Male spawning success was inversely related to availability of oviposition substrate, but was not affected either by density or tank size. Location of a territory and its size also influenced spawning success. Males with bigger territories had higher spawning success. A “carryover” effect of neighbors was observed; males with reproductively active neighbors spawned more often than those with less successful neighbors. Interference with spawning was affected both by tank size and density. Agonistic behavior of breeding males was not affected by any manipulation, but it was positively associated with male spawning success at high but not at low densities. In all treatments the mortality of breeding males was approximately 8 times as high as that of females, suggesting that, under these experimental conditions, the cost of reproducing is substantially higher for males. Comparisons between breeding pupfish in these experiments and in natural environments provide a basis for understanding the selective pressures that have favored the maintenance of these extremely plastic breeding systems.