Premium
Hippocampal malrotation is an anatomic variant and has no clinical significance in MRI ‐negative temporal lobe epilepsy
Author(s) -
Tsai MengHan,
Vaughan David N.,
Perchyonok Yuliya,
Fitt Greg J.,
Scheffer Ingrid E.,
Berkovic Samuel F.,
Jackson Graeme D.
Publication year - 2016
Publication title -
epilepsia
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 2.687
H-Index - 191
eISSN - 1528-1167
pISSN - 0013-9580
DOI - 10.1111/epi.13505
Subject(s) - temporal lobe , hippocampal formation , epilepsy , hippocampal sclerosis , magnetic resonance imaging , medicine , population , lobe , psychology , radiology , pathology , neuroscience , environmental health
Summary Objective There is considerable difficulty in diagnosing hippocampal malrotation ( HIMAL ), with different criteria of variable reliability. Here we assess qualitative and quantitative criteria in HIMAL diagnosis and explore the role of HIMAL in magnetic resonance imaging ( MRI )–negative temporal lobe epilepsy ( TLE ). Methods We studied the MRI of 155 adult patients with MRI ‐negative TLE and 103 healthy volunteers, and we asked (1) what are the qualitative and quantitative features that allow a reliable diagnosis of HIMAL , (2) how common is HIMAL in a normal control population, and (3) is HIMAL congruent with the epileptogenic side in MRI ‐negative TLE . Results We found that the features that are most correlated with the expert diagnosis of HIMAL are hippocampal shape change with hippocampal diameter ratio > 0.8, lack of normal lateral convex margin, and a deep dominant inferior temporal sulcus ( DITS ) with DITS height ratio > 0.6. In a blinded analysis, a consensus diagnosis of unilateral or bilateral HIMAL was made in 25 of 103 controls (24.3% of people, 14.6% of hippocampi—14 left, six right, 10 bilateral) that did not differ from 155 lesion‐negative TLE patients where 25 had HIMAL (16.1% of patients, 11.6% of hippocampi—12 left, two right, 11 bilateral). Of the 12 with left HIMAL only, 9 had seizures arising from the left temporal lobe, whereas 3 had right‐sided seizures. Of the two with right HIMAL only, both had seizures arising from the left temporal lobe. Significance HIMAL is an anatomic variant commonly found in controls. HIMAL is also an incidental nonpathologic finding in adult MRI ‐negative TLE and should not influence surgical decision making.