Premium
The Weakness Of Symbolic Boundaries: Handling Exclusion Among Montevideo's Squatters
Author(s) -
ÁlvarezRivadulla María José
Publication year - 2017
Publication title -
international journal of urban and regional research
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 2.456
H-Index - 114
eISSN - 1468-2427
pISSN - 0309-1317
DOI - 10.1111/1468-2427.12450
Subject(s) - dignity , the symbolic , sociology , neighbourhood (mathematics) , settlement (finance) , human settlement , participant observation , social exclusion , boundary (topology) , geography , gender studies , economic growth , economic geography , political science , social science , business , economics , law , psychology , archaeology , mathematical analysis , mathematics , finance , psychoanalysis , payment
Abstract This article argues that material conditions limit the possibilities of symbolic boundaries becoming markers of social differentiation, especially among stigmatized groups. Using squatter settlements in Montevideo, Uruguay, as a case study, it shows that symbolic boundaries are hard to maintain when material conditions and the stigmas associated with certain places work against them. Based on participant observation and oral histories, it analyses how squatters experienced the move to a squatter settlement. It argues that, for many, it was a way to resist exclusion, a struggle to belong to the city and to protect a social position that structural changes under neoliberalism had put at risk. This required engaging in difficult symbolic boundary work to distinguish themselves from cantegriles —poor and crowded older shantytowns—and claim dignity as workers and residents of a regular city neighbourhood. Yet, there were many limits to their fight in an increasingly fragmented city. Through follow‐up visits to several settlements over almost two decades and tracking the case in the local press, through available survey data and secondary literature, this article offers a longitudinal perspective of symbolic boundaries in the making.