Premium
Gentrification in H ong K ong? Epistemology vs. Ontology
Author(s) -
Ley David,
Teo Sin Yih
Publication year - 2014
Publication title -
international journal of urban and regional research
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 2.456
H-Index - 114
eISSN - 1468-2427
pISSN - 0309-1317
DOI - 10.1111/1468-2427.12109
Subject(s) - gentrification , sociology , ideology , state (computer science) , argument (complex analysis) , power (physics) , cityscape , political economy , political science , law , politics , economics , economic growth , art , biochemistry , chemistry , physics , algorithm , quantum mechanics , computer science , visual arts
This article examines the transferability of the concept of gentrification away from its A nglo‐ A merican heartland to the cities of A sia Pacific and specifically H ong K ong. An epistemological argument challenges such theoretical licence, claiming that conceptual overreach represents another example of A nglo‐ A merican hegemony asserting the primacy of its concepts in other societies and cultures. Past research suggests that if gentrification exists in A sia Pacific cities it bears some definite regional specificities of urban form, state direction and, most surprising from a Western perspective, a potentially progressive dimension for some impacted residents. Closer examination of urban discourse in H ong K ong is conducted through analysis of E nglish and C hinese language newspapers. In both instances, gentrification is barely used to describe the pervasive processes of urban redevelopment, which otherwise receive abundant coverage. Interviews with local housing experts confirm the marginality of gentrification in academic and public discourse, and the power of a local ideology that sees urban (re)development unproblematically as a means of upward social mobility. However, in the decade‐long housing bust after 1997, growing inequality has encouraged a nascent class analysis of the property market, an ontological awakening that may prove more favourable to the identification of gentrification in an A sia Pacific idiom.