Open AccessNovel Internationally Verified Method Reports Desmoplastic Reaction as the Most Significant Prognostic Feature For Disease-specific Survival in Stage II Colorectal Cancer
Author(s) -
Ines P. Nearchou,
Yoshiki Kajiwara,
Satsuki Mochizuki,
David J. Harrison,
Peter D. Caie,
Hideki Ueno
Publication year - 2019
Publication title -
the american journal of surgical pathology
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 2.625
H-Index - 210
eISSN - 1532-0979
pISSN - 0147-5185
DOI - 10.1097/pas.0000000000001304
Subject(s) - hazard ratio , proportional hazards model , colorectal cancer , stage (stratigraphy) , medicine , cohort , oncology , feature (linguistics) , multivariate analysis , cancer , disease , pathology , confidence interval , biology , paleontology , linguistics , philosophy
Multiple histopathologic features have been reported as candidates for predicting aggressive stage II colorectal cancer (CRC). These include tumor budding (TB), poorly differentiated clusters (PDC), Crohn-like lymphoid reaction and desmoplastic reaction (DR) categorization. Although their individual prognostic significance has been established, their association with disease-specific survival (DSS) has not been compared in stage II CRC. This study aimed to evaluate and compare the prognostic value of the above features in a Japanese (n=283) and a Scottish (n=163) cohort, as well as to compare 2 different reporting methodologies: analyzing each feature from across every tissue slide from the whole tumor and a more efficient methodology reporting each feature from a single slide containing the deepest tumor invasion. In the Japanese cohort, there was an excellent agreement between the multi-slide and single-slide methodologies for TB, PDC, and DR (κ=0.798 to 0.898) and a good agreement when assessing Crohn-like lymphoid reaction (κ=0.616). TB (hazard ratio [HR]=1.773; P=0.016), PDC (HR=1.706; P=0.028), and DR (HR=2.982; P<0.001) based on the single-slide method were all significantly associated with DSS. DR was the only candidate feature reported to be a significant independent prognostic factor (HR=2.982; P<0.001) with both multi-slide and single-slide methods. The single-slide result was verified in the Scottish cohort, where multivariate Cox regression analysis reported that DR was the only significant independent feature (HR=1.778; P=0.002) associated with DSS. DR was shown to be the most significant of all the analyzed histopathologic features to predict disease-specific death in stage II CRC. We further show that analyzing the features from a single-slide containing the tumor's deepest invasion is an efficient and quicker method of evaluation.