Regional Gene Therapy with Transduced Human Cells: The Influence of “Cell Dose” on Bone Repair

Regional gene therapy using a lentiviral vector containing the BMP-2 complementary DNA (cDNA) has been shown to heal critical-sized bone defects in rodent models. An appropriate "cellular dose" needs to be defined for eventual translation into human trials. The purpose of this study was to evaluate bone defect healing potential and quality using three different doses of transduced human bone marrow cells (HBMCs). HBMCs were transduced with a lentiviral vector containing either BMP-2 or green fluorescent protein (GFP). All cells were loaded onto compression-resistant matrices and implanted in the bone defect of athymic rats. Treatment groups included femoral defects that were treated with a low-dose (1 × 10 6 cells), standard-dose (5 × 10 6 cells), and high-dose (1.5 × 10 7 cells) HBMCs transduced with lentiviral vector containing BMP-2 cDNA. The three control groups were bone defects treated with HBMCs that were either nontransduced or transduced with vector containing GFP. All animals were sacrificed at 12 weeks. The bone formed in each defect was evaluated with plain radiographs, microcomputed tomography (microCT), histomorphometric analysis, and biomechanical testing. Bone defects treated with higher doses of BMP-2-producing cells were more likely to have healed (6/14 of the low-dose group; 12/14 of the standard-dose group; 14/14 of the high-dose group; χ 2 (2) = 15.501, p  < 0.001). None of the bone defects in the control groups had healed. Bone defects treated with high dose and standard dose of BMP-2-producing cells consistently outperformed those treated with a low dose in terms of bone formation, as assessed by microCT and histomorphometry, and biomechanical parameters. However, statistical significance was only seen between defects treated with high dose and low dose. Larger doses of BMP-2-producing cells were associated with a higher likelihood of forming heterotopic ossification. Femurs treated with a standard- and high-dose BMP-2-producing cells demonstrated similar healing and biomechanical properties. Increased doses of BMP-2 delivered through higher cell doses have the potential to heal large bone defects. Adapting regional gene therapy for use in humans will require a balance between promoting bone repair and limiting heterotopic ossification. Impact statement Critical bone loss may result from complex traumatic bone injury (i.e., open fracture or blast injury), revision total joint arthroplasty, and spine pseudoarthrosis. This is a challenging clinical problem to treat and regional gene therapy is an innovative means of addressing it. This study provides information regarding the quantity of cells or "cell dose" of transduced cells needed to treat a critical-sized bone defect in a rat model. This information may be extrapolated for use in humans in future trials.