Crowding‐induced responses in a geometrid moth revisited: a field experiment

In Lepidoptera, effects of larval crowding on life history traits may manifest themselves as changes in growth rate and duration of larval period. For the outbreaking geometrid moth, Epirrita autumnata , impacts of crowding have been shown in earlier laboratory studies, and these responses were modified by diet quality. In this study, the aim was to find out the specific nature of crowding effects of E. autumnata in the field. E. autumnata larvae were reared individually and in groups in mesh bags on mountain birch, both on good and poor quality foliage. Three field experiments were carried out with different densities in the crowded treatment (12, 21 and 45 larvae per 100 short shoots of mountain birch), simulating intermediate to severe outbreaks. The study revealed the density interval (12–21) within which impacts of crowding become evident. Significant effects were mostly found with the two highest densities in the crowded treatment combined with poor foliage quality. In those treatments, crowding resulted in 8–12% and 24–33% decrease in pupal mass and larval survival, respectively. The results of the present field experiments, however, did not corroborate the results of earlier laboratory studies: duration of larval period was not substantially affected, net effects of crowding were negative and interactions between crowding and foliage quality were contrary to those obtained in earlier laboratory studies. In many other Lepidoptera as well, the knowledge on responses to crowding may be mostly qualitative since most crowding experiments have been conducted in laboratory.