Open AccessInterlaboratory comparison study of calibration standards for foraminiferal Mg/Ca thermometry
Author(s) -
Greaves M.,
Caillon N.,
Rebaubier H.,
Bartoli G.,
Bohaty S.,
Cacho I.,
Clarke L.,
Cooper M.,
Daunt C.,
Delaney M.,
deMenocal P.,
Dutton A.,
Eggins S.,
Elderfield H.,
GarbeSchoenberg D.,
Goddard E.,
Green D.,
Groeneveld J.,
Hastings D.,
Hathorne E.,
Kimoto K.,
Klinkhammer G.,
Labeyrie L.,
Lea D. W.,
Marchitto T.,
MartínezBotí M. A.,
Mortyn P. G.,
Ni Y.,
Nuernberg D.,
Paradis G.,
Pena L.,
Quinn T.,
Rosenthal Y.,
Russell A.,
Sagawa T.,
Sosdian S.,
Stott L.,
Tachikawa K.,
Tappa E.,
Thunell R.,
Wilson P. A.
Publication year - 2008
Publication title -
geochemistry, geophysics, geosystems
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 1.928
H-Index - 136
ISSN - 1525-2027
DOI - 10.1029/2008gc001974
Subject(s) - repeatability , reproducibility , calcite , chemistry , analytical chemistry (journal) , accuracy and precision , calibration , chromatography , carbonate , dissolution , mineralogy , mathematics , statistics , organic chemistry
An interlaboratory study of Mg/Ca and Sr/Ca ratios in three commercially available carbonate reference materials (BAM RS3, CMSI 1767, and ECRM 752‐1) was performed with the participation of 25 laboratories that determine foraminiferal Mg/Ca ratios worldwide. These reference materials containing Mg/Ca in the range of foraminiferal calcite (0.8 mmol/mol to 6 mmol/mol) were circulated with a dissolution protocol for analysis. Participants were asked to make replicate dissolutions of the powdered samples and to analyze them using the instruments and calibration standards routinely used in their laboratories. Statistical analysis was performed in accordance with the International Standardization Organization standard 5725, which is based on the analysis of variance (ANOVA) technique. Repeatability (RSD r %), an indicator of intralaboratory precision, for Mg/Ca determinations in solutions after centrifuging increased with decreasing Mg/Ca, ranging from 0.78% at Mg/Ca = 5.56 mmol/mol to 1.15% at Mg/Ca = 0.79 mmol/mol. Reproducibility (RSD R %), an indicator of the interlaboratory method precision, for Mg/Ca determinations in centrifuged solutions was noticeably worse than repeatability, ranging from 4.5% at Mg/Ca = 5.56 mmol/mol to 8.7% at Mg/Ca = 0.79 mmol/mol. Results of this study show that interlaboratory variability is dominated by inconsistencies among instrument calibrations and highlight the need to improve interlaboratory compatibility. Additionally, the study confirmed the suitability of these solid standards as reference materials for foraminiferal Mg/Ca (and Sr/Ca) determinations, provided that appropriate procedures are adopted to minimize and to monitor possible contamination from silicate mineral phases.