Meta ‐substituent effects on organoiridium‐catalyzed ortho ‐hydrogen isotope exchange

Reports in the literature appear to differ on the effects of some C3 substituents on the relative efficiencies of isotope exchange in the nonidentical C2‐ and C6‐positions catalyzed by organoiridium complexes. Controlled experiments were conducted using a set of model substrates in attempts to clarify these effects. The results clearly showed that, in common with most previous findings, alkyl substituents at C3 reduced the rate of isotope incorporation into C2 relative to C6, as expected on steric grounds. In contrast, all substituents possessing electron lone pairs resulted in a lessening of the inhibition of C2‐vs‐C6 labeling or promoted C2 labeling to such a degree that it became faster than that at C6. NMR measurements on equimolar mixtures of active iridium complex with selected substrates revealed that the ratios of C2‐ and C6‐iridacycles present in solution correlated with the relative rates of ortho ‐deuteration in the rate studies. The results of the two studies, taken together, suggest that conventional explanations for the origin of the positive meta ‐effect may not be adequate for the present system. An alternative hypothesis is advanced. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.