C omparisons of ectomycorrhizae on pinyon pines ( P inus edulis ; P inaceae ) across extremes of soil type and herbivory

Using field and greenhouse studies, we examined the relationships among pinyon pines ( Pinus edulis ), their ectomycorrhizal mutualists, and their moth herbivores as a function of soil fertility. We studied two soil types—the ash and cinder soils of the San Francisco volcanic field and nearby sandy loam soils. In the field, pinyons growing in cinders suffered from reduced moisture, negative nitrogen mineralization rates, low phosphate levels, reduced growth, and high moth herbivory relative to pinyons growing in sandy loam. Pinyons growing in cinders also had twofold higher levels of ectomycorrhizal colonization than their noncinder counterparts. Similarly, in the greenhouse, seedlings grown in cinders had higher levels of ectomycorrhizal colonization and greater numbers of ectomycorrhizae than seedlings grown in sandy loam. Seedling shoot growth was significantly enhanced by ectomycorrhizae in both soils. These patterns support three conclusions. First, field and greenhouse studies demonstrated that trees growing in nutrient‐poor soils had higher levels of ectomycorrhizal colonization than trees growing in better soils. Second, across soil types, variation in ectomycorrhizal colonization was better predicted by soil fertility than by herbivory. However, herbivory negatively affected ectomycorrhizae in the stressful cinder environment. Third, although mycorrhizae can be parasitic under some conditions, ectomycorrhizae had mutualistic impacts on pinyon seedlings across the environmental extremes we studied.