Premium
Neither a Bazaar nor a cathedral: The interplay between structure and agency in Wikipedia's role system
Author(s) -
Arazy Ofer,
LifshitzAssaf Hila,
Balila Adam
Publication year - 2019
Publication title -
journal of the association for information science and technology
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 0.903
H-Index - 145
eISSN - 2330-1643
pISSN - 2330-1635
DOI - 10.1002/asi.24076
Subject(s) - agency (philosophy) , linkage (software) , mechanism (biology) , peer production , production (economics) , knowledge management , computer science , sociology , epistemology , economics , biology , biochemistry , philosophy , macroeconomics , gene , social science
Roles provide a key coordination mechanism in peer‐production. Whereas one stream in the literature has focused on the structural responsibilities associated with roles, another has stressed the emergent nature of work. To date, these streams have proceeded largely in parallel. In seeking to enhance our understanding of the tension between structure and agency in peer‐production, we investigated the interplay between structural and emergent roles. Our study explored the breadth of structural roles in Wikipedia (English version) and their linkage to various forms of activities. Our analyses show that despite the latitude in selecting their mode of participation, participants' structural and emergent roles are tightly coupled. Our discussion highlights that: (a) participants often stay close to the “production ground floor” despite the assignment into structural roles; and (b) there are typical modifications in activity patterns associated with role‐assignment, namely: functional specialization, multispecialization, defunctionalization, changes in communication patterns, management of identity, and role definition. We contribute to theory of coordination and roles, as well as provide some practical implications.