The Puzzle of Petitionary Prayer

Th e fact that our asking God to do something can make a diff erence to what he does underwrites the point of petitionary prayer. Here, however, a puzzle arises: Either doing what we ask is the best God can do or it is not. If it is, then our asking won't make any diff erence to whether he does it. If it is not, then our asking won't make any diff erence to whether he does it. So, our ask- ing won't make any diff erence to whether God does it. Our asking is therefore pointless. In this paper, we try to solve this puzzle without denying either that God must do the best he can or that petitioning God can make a diff erence to what he does. Father, we pray for your holy Catholic Church; that we all may be one. Grant that every member of the Church may truly and humbly serve you; that your Name may be glorifi ed by all people. We pray for all bishops, priests, and deacons; that they may be faithful ministers of your Word and Sacraments. We pray for all who govern and hold authority in the nations of the world; that there may be justice and peace on the earth. Give us grace to do your will in all that we undertake; that our works may fi nd favor in your sight. Have compassion on those who suff er from any grief or trouble; that they may be delivered from their distress. Give to the departed eternal rest; let light perpetual shine upon them. We praise you for your saints who have entered into joy; may we also come to share in your heavenly kingdom. Let us pray for our own needs and the needs of others. 1