Differential Use of Transcription Activation Function 2 Domain of the Vitamin D Receptor by 1,25-Dihydroxyvitamin D3 and Its A Ring-Modified Analogs

Analogs of 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 (1,25D3) can be used to elucidate details of vitamin D receptor (VDR) activation. The A ring-modified analog, (TN-2) has 15-fold less affinity for VDR, but its transcriptional activity is diminished 1000-fold. Likewise, the ability of TN-2 to induce a protease-resistant conformation in VDR is 1/1000 that of 1,25D3. The stability of the VDR-TN-2 complexes is also significantly lower than VDR-1,25D3 complexes. Mapping the VDR-binding site of TN-2 showed that it had a significantly greater requirement for transcription activation function 2 (AF-2) residues than 1,25D3 did. These results suggest that the increased requirement for AF-2 residues that was induced by the A ring modifications is associated with diminished receptor activation. To determine whether restoring the potency of TN-2 by additional structural modifications would change the requirements for AF-2 residues, we synthesized hybrid analogs with 1beta-hydroxymethyl-3-epi groups and with dimethyl groups at positions 26 and 27 of the side chain, without or with a double bond between CD ring positions 16 and 17. We found that the side chain modification enhanced transcriptional activity 150-fold, increased the ability of the receptor to form a protease-resistant conformation 100-fold, and stabilized the VDR-analog complexes. The addition of the 16-ene group further reduced the analog's dissociation rate and increased its potency in the protease assays. These functional changes in the hybrid analogs were associated with a significant reduction in interaction with AF-2 residues. We conclude that there is an inverse relationship between analogs' potencies and their interaction with AF-2 residues of VDR.