Monaural level discrimination under dichotic conditions

The ability to make judgments about the stimulus at one ear when a stimulus is simultaneously presented to the other ear was tested. Specifically, subjects discriminated the level of a 600 Hz target tone presented at the left ear while an identical-frequency distractor was simultaneously presented at the other ear. When there was no distractor, threshold was 0.7 dB. Threshold increased to 1.1 dB when a distractor with a fixed phase and level was introduced contra-aurally to the target. Further increases in threshold were observed when an across-presentation variability was introduced into the distractor phase (threshold of 1.6 dB) or level (threshold of 5.8 dB). When both the distractor level and phase varied, the largest threshold of 7.3 dB was obtained. These increases in threshold cannot be predicted by common binaural models, which assume that a target stimulus at one ear can be processed without interference from the stimulus at the nontarget ear. The measured thresholds are consistent with a model that utilizes two binaural dimensions that roughly correspond to the loudness and the position of a fused binaural image. The results show that, with binaurally fused tonal stimuli, subjects are unable to listen to one ear.