A metacognitive account of phenomenal force

According to phenomenal conservatism or dogmatism, perceptual experiences can give us immediate justification for beliefs about the external world in virtue of having a distinctive kind of phenomenal character—namely phenomenal force. I present three cases to show that phenomenal force is neither pervasive among nor exclusive to perceptual experiences. The plausibility of such cases calls out for explanation. I argue that contrary to a long‐held assumption, phenomenal force is a separate, non‐perceptual state generated by some metacognitive mechanisms that monitor one's first‐order mental processes and states. This new account advances our understanding of the nature of phenomenal force.