Premium
Encouraging pointing with the right hand, but not the left hand, gives right‐handed 3‐year‐olds a linguistic advantage
Author(s) -
Mumford Katherine H.,
Aussems Suzanne,
Kita Sotaro
Publication year - 2023
Publication title -
developmental science
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
SCImago Journal Rank - 2.801
H-Index - 127
eISSN - 1467-7687
pISSN - 1363-755X
DOI - 10.1111/desc.13315
Subject(s) - psychology , gesture , cognitive psychology , lateralization of brain function , right handed , left and right , verb , deep linguistic processing , task (project management) , vocabulary , affect (linguistics) , laterality , linguistics , developmental psychology , communication , philosophy , physics , management , structural engineering , nuclear physics , neutrino , economics , engineering
Abstract Previous research has shown a strong positive association between right‐handed gesturing and vocabulary development. However, the causal nature of this relationship remains unclear. In the current study, we tested whether gesturing with the right hand enhances linguistic processing in the left hemisphere, which is contralateral to the right hand. We manipulated the gesture hand children used in pointing tasks to test whether it would affect their performance. In either a linguistic task (verb learning) or a non‐linguistic control task (memory), 131 typically developing right‐handed 3‐year‐olds were encouraged to use either their right hand or left hand to respond. While encouraging children to use a specific hand to indicate their responses had no effect on memory performance, encouraging children to use the right hand to respond, compared to the left hand, significantly improved their verb learning performance. This study is the first to show that manipulating the hand with which children are encouraged to gesture gives them a linguistic advantage. Language lateralization in healthy right‐handed children typically involves a dominant left hemisphere. Producing right‐handed gestures may therefore lead to increased activation in the left hemisphere which may, in turn, facilitate forming and accessing lexical representations. It is important to note that this study manipulated gesture handedness among right‐handers and does therefore not support the practice of encouraging children to become right‐handed in manual activities. Research Highlights Right‐handed 3‐year‐olds were instructed to point to indicate their answers exclusively with their right or left hand in either a memory or verb learning task. Right‐handed pointing was associated with improved verb generalization performance, but not improved memory performance. Thus, gesturing with the right hand, compared to the left hand, gives right‐handed 3‐year‐olds an advantage in a linguistic but not a non‐linguistic task. Right‐handed pointing might lead to increased activation in the left hemisphere and facilitate forming and accessing lexical representations.