Comparison of valvar and right ventricular function following transcatheter and surgical pulmonary valve replacement

Objective Trans‐catheter (TC) pulmonary valve replacement (PVR) has become common practice for patients with right ventricular outflow tract obstruction (RVOTO) and/or pulmonic insufficiency (PI). Our aim was to compare PVR and right ventricular (RV) function of patients who received TC vs surgical PVR. Design Retrospective review of echocardiograms obtained at three time points: before, immediately after PVR, and most recent. Patients Sixty‐two patients (median age 19 years, median follow‐up 25 months) following TC (N = 32) or surgical (N = 30) PVR at Yale‐New Haven Hospital were included. Outcome Measures Pulmonary valve and right ventricular function before, immediately after, and most recently after PVR. Results At baseline, the TC group had predominant RVOTO (74% vs 10%, P  < .001), and moderate‐severe PI was less common (61% vs 100%, P  < .001). Immediate post‐procedural PVR function was good throughout. At last follow‐up, the TC group had preserved valve function, but the surgical group did not (moderate RVOTO: 6% vs 41%, P  < .001; >mild PI: 0% vs 24%, P  = .003). Patients younger than 17 years at surgical PVR had the highest risk of developing PVR dysfunction, while PVR function in follow‐up was similar in adults. Looking at RV size and function, both groups had a decline in RV size following PVR. However, while RV function remained stable in the TC group, there was a transient postoperative decline in the surgical group. Conclusions TC PVR in patients age <17 years is associated with better PVR function in follow‐up compared to surgical valves. There was a transient decline in RV function following surgical but not TC PVR. TC PVR should therefore be the first choice in children who are considered for PVR, whenever possible.