Potential aposematism in an insular tree species: are signals dishonest early in ontogeny?

Recent investigations have suggested that some plants are aposematic. Our understanding of how aposematism varies through plant ontogeny, however, is incomplete. Furthermore, the potential for lower leaf surfaces to signal to vertebrate herbivores that are viewing leaves from below has not been investigated. Here, we investigate ontogenetic changes in leaf colour in Pseudopanax crassifolius (Araliaceae), a tree species that is endemic to New Zealand. We demonstrate that P. crassifolius produces lateral leaf spines that peak in size during the sapling stage of development. Spots of brightly coloured tissues on the upper leaf surfaces may be warning signals. The intensity of these signals, however, peaked at the seedling stage, providing a dishonest signal of defence. Conversely, signals on lower leaf surfaces peaked in the sapling stage, providing an honest defensive signal later in ontogeny. Lateral leaf spines and all potential warning colours were absent in adults, after they grow above the reach of the largest known native megaherbivores (moa – Aves: Dinornithiformes). Overall, these results suggest that aposematism may vary predictably through plant ontogeny in response to the changing perspective of herbivores as plants grow vertically.