Pattern of Chromosome 16q Loss Differs between an Atypical Proliferative Lesion and an Intraductal or Invasive Ductal Carcinoma Occurring Subsequently in the Same Area of the Breast

Atypical proliferative lesions of the breast, such as atypical ductal hyperplasia and atypical papilloma, are considered to be precursors of breast carcinomas and have frequently been shown to have loss of heterozygosity (LOH) on chromosome 16q at the DNA level. We evaluated whether an atypical proliferative lesion and a carcinoma that subsequently occurred in the same area of the ipsilateral breast were of identical clonal origin in seven patients. Using DNA isolated from microdissected archival tissue of epithelial components of both the biopsy specimen of the atypical proliferative lesion and the mastectomy specimen of the carcinoma, the pattern of LOH on 16q was compared between these two lesions using polymerase chain reaction -microsatellite LOH analysis. As a control, LOH on 16q was examined in 13 cases of usual ductal hyperplasia, 10 usual papillomas, and 6 atypical ductal hyperplasias. In the seven cases, LOH on 16q was detected in three of the six atypical proliferative lesions and in five of the seven carcinomas, but the allele with LOH or a deleted region always differed between the two. LOH was detected in both atypical proliferative lesions and carcinomas in one case, only in the atypical proliferative lesion in two cases, and only in carcinomas in three cases. In the controls, LOH on 16q was absent in usual ductal hyperplasias or usual papillomas but was detected in two of six atypical ductal hyperplasias. Although atypical proliferative lesions were frequently confirmed to be of clonal nature with LOH on 16q, these lesions and carcinomas were considered to be clones, probably originated from a field with these clones.