
Are Russellian Indexicals Eliminable?
Author(s) -
Sebastián Sanhueza
Publication year - 2020
Publication title -
síntesis. revista de filosofía
Language(s) - English
Resource type - Journals
ISSN - 2452-4476
DOI - 10.15691/0718-5448vol3iss2a333
Subject(s) - meaning (existential) , epistemology , philosophy , linguistics , natural (archaeology) , natural kind , contrast (vision) , computer science , identity (music) , history , artificial intelligence , aesthetics , archaeology
It is widely thought that, in his later work An Inquiry into Meaning and Truth, Bertrand Russell argued that our natural languages could in principle do away with indexicals. This brief piece, by contrast, aims to show that, instead of suggesting the potential eliminability of such expressions, Russell outlined a semantic account of indexicals according to which such expressions fundamentally depend on the perspectival way in which they refer to worldly items. If correct, this proposal would not only show that, in Russell’s later work, the meaning of expressions like indexicals is not exhaustively determined by the items they refer to: it would also show that Russell did not mean to eliminate indexicals from our natural languages at all.